An extension giving residents until November 19 to submit initial written comments on the Mahoney’s Lane housing proposal prompted questions about public notice and the Conservation Commission’s authority to issue a statement at its November 12 meeting.
Conservation Commission Chair Michael King said the board extended the comment period by one week due to a delay in posting the previous meeting’s video. Select board member Nicole Lynch questioned how residents would learn about the extension before the new deadline, given the weekly newspapers’ publication schedules.
“If it’s a press release, is it going to the press?” Lynch asked. She noted the weekly papers had already gone to publication, meaning readers might not learn about the extension until the new deadline.
King said newspapers could update their online editions, and the town could post the information on its website.
“There’s a multitude of ways that the information can be conveyed,” he said.
The exchange followed King’s reading of a proposed commission statement describing additional technical reviews of the project at 1–7 Mahoney’s Lane. Dennis Mahoney & Sons, Inc. proposes replacing seven rental units with seven single-family homes. The project hearing was not reopened and remains scheduled for December 2 at the Old Rochester Regional High School auditorium.
King said two additional independent reviews funded by the applicant would examine the property’s wetland resource areas, including historical information, and the proposed stormwater management plan. He said the findings would be presented at the December hearing.
During the reading, Cynthia Martin challenged King’s distinction between reading a press release and discussing the application. She also questioned the participation of members who requested recusal.
“I don’t know how you can talk about just reading a statement versus a discussion,” Martin said.
King maintained that the statement concerned the review process rather than the project’s merits.
“It is simply a procedural vote to issue a public statement,” he said.
Commission members Ella McIntire and David Nicolosi, who had previously recused themselves from the project, repeated their recusals during the exchange.
Nicki Demakis questioned whether King could issue the statement on behalf of the commission without approval from a quorum of disinterested members.
“I think it has to be tabled, and I think you have to get a quorum of disinterested members to approve the statement,” she said.
King said he had received guidance from an attorney with the State Ethics Commission about presenting the statement.
Demakis also challenged its characterization of the peer reviews.
“When it’s paid for by the applicant, that’s not necessarily an indication that those opinions are disinterested,” she said.
King responded that applicant-funded review was part of the statutory process.
Brandon Faneuf, president and founder of Ecosystem Solutions, Inc., which provides conservation consulting services to the town, recommended abandoning the release in light of the objections.
King thanked Faneuf and moved to the next agenda item without clarifying whether his earlier direction to release the statement had been withdrawn.
In other business, the commission voted to issue an enforcement order for 47 Cove Street after consultants reported concrete work beyond the scope of a May 2025 emergency authorization. Following discussion, members gave the owners 90 days to begin pursuing after-the-fact wetlands permitting and a Chapter 91 license or remove the wall.
At 104 Angelica Avenue, members supported seeking access to town counsel through the town administrator after consultants reported receiving no response to an enforcement order and follow-up correspondence concerning salt marsh mowing.
Faneuf outlined seeking a court injunction through town counsel or asking the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection to take over enforcement. Members favored pursuing the town counsel route first.
The commission also reviewed restoration options for 87 Fairhaven Road, where consultants said exploratory trenches revealed wood chips over older fill and underlying wetland soils.
Consultants recommended removing the chips and underlying fill within the affected area and creating a slope between the wetland and lawn. Property owner Paul Sullivan said he wanted his consultant Chris Capone to address the proposal.
Continued coordination and a site visit were planned. No final restoration plan was approved, and the cause of neighboring flooding remained unresolved.
Members also reviewed a proposed Select Board policy requiring audio and video recording of appointed board and committee meetings. Discussion focused on who would be responsible for providing the required recording notices.
The commission issued a favorable determination for a septic system replacement at 3 North Road. The proposed system would serve the existing two-bedroom house while providing capacity for a possible future third bedroom.
Mattapoisett Conservation Commission
By Jeanne Hopkins