To The Editor:
The ongoing debate in Marion over whether to convert a cherished open space at Island Wharf into temporary parking is about much more than just convenience – it’s a textbook example of what ecologist Garrett Hardin famously called the Tragedy of the Commons.
At first glance, the proposal seems practical. The Marion Select Board recently agreed to create approximately 75 temporary lined parking spots at Island Wharf to address parking shortages in the village. A subcommittee has been tasked with studying the issue in more detail.
But the area in question is not just any open space. It’s a grassy, waterfront commons used year-round by families for picnics, by residents attending concerts at the bandstand, and by patrons of local businesses. It’s also used by boaters with trailers, who currently face parking limits and logistical challenges. Now, some town officials want to prioritize that space for boat trailer parking – at the expense of nearly everyone else.
The harbormaster argues that without access to the grassy area, boaters may park on side streets during their allowed 72-hour window, which he says could be a “nuisance” for officials and boaters alike. But it’s worth questioning whether that’s a compelling justification for turning a shared open space into a temporary storage lot. Is preserving government convenience more important than protecting a valued public asset?
One Select Board member raised a valid concern: that using the green space for boat parking could deter community use altogether. And rightly so. If a family wants to enjoy a picnic or attend a concert, they shouldn’t have to navigate around parked trailers and marine equipment. Safety also becomes an issue – especially when crowds and vehicles compete in the same congested space.
This is where Hardin’s Tragedy of the Commons comes into sharp focus. In his theory, individuals acting in their self-interest can exploit shared resources – like open land – until those resources are degraded or lost altogether. That’s precisely what’s at stake here: short-term convenience for one group could destroy the long-term value of this commons for everyone.
So what’s the solution?
Hardin didn’t believe the commons could survive without some form of management. In this case, that could mean designated off-site parking for boaters, shuttle services, stricter time-based parking regulations, or permit systems that discourage overuse. Most importantly, the town must reaffirm its commitment to preserving shared spaces for passive recreation – a need that is just as valid, if not more so, than vehicle storage.
Island Wharf is not just a patch of grass; it’s a symbol of what makes Marion special. Sacrificing that for short-term convenience would be a mistake we’d all pay for.
Sincerely,
Eileen J. Marum
The views expressed in the “Letters to the Editor” column are not necessarily those of The Wanderer, its staff or advertisers. The Wanderer will gladly accept any and all correspondence relating to timely and pertinent issues in the great Marion, Mattapoisett and Rochester area, provided they include the author’s name, address and phone number for verification. We cannot publish anonymous, unsigned or unconfirmed submissions. The Wanderer reserves the right to edit, condense and otherwise alter submissions for purposes of clarity and/or spacing considerations. The Wanderer may choose to not run letters that thank businesses, and The Wanderer has the right to edit letters to omit business names. The Wanderer also reserves the right to deny publication of any submitted correspondence. All letters must be typed and submitted directly to: news@wanderer.com.