Brothers Motor around the Vineyard

In the latest of what The Wanderer could have packaged as a series of annual adventures on the high seas, the Perkins brothers of Mattapoisett did the kind of thing two teenagers typically talk about on a quiet, summer day but would probably never try.

            In the course of one weekend morning, they boarded their 13-foot, inflatable boat and circumnavigated Martha’s Vineyard.

            “There’s something about pushing the limits and doing things beyond what others think is ‘normal’ or ‘okay.’ Heck, my brother was told the day before, ‘… that’s not possible, no way you can do that ….’ But, hey, we did it,” said Peter Perkins. “It’s been a thought for years now, and last Friday it came up in conversation with the guys … ‘hey, Haakon, let’s do a boat ride tomorrow – go around the Vineyard!’”

            Born and raised in Mattapoisett, the Perkins brothers are not teenagers. Peter is 31 and Haakon 28. They work in the family insurance business, but their free time has always been around boats and the water.

            “Ever since I was little,” says Peter, recalling days lobstering on his father’s 25-footer, “I’ve been on boats of all sizes.”

            Albeit a decade or more into adult life, the Perkins brothers had their teenage musings about the Vineyard, and the more they talked about it, the more feasible it became.

            “It was my first time around the Vineyard, I always wanted to do it,” said Peter. “I’ve never really taken it seriously until literally two days before we decided to do it. … We tried to be back before noon.”

            The reason for that is fairly basic. The ocean typically awakes from its summer slumber like a sheet of glass, but later the same day, roars with activity. Sunrise was an easy choice.

            “It was pretty late that (Saturday) night, and we ended up going the next day, Sunday (August 25). So Saturday we planned our route, charted our course, checked the weather and tides, packed food, snacks, water, and of course, extra gas,” said Peter.

            Their 20-horsepower inflatable could comfortably carry two passengers and a lot of rope. They knew they might need it for the 70 to 80-foot depth around Gay Head.

            This much rope wouldn’t get the job done, however, in Norway, where the family also has a small boat. Being of 50% Norwegian heritage, Peter and Haakon navigate those waters as well.

            “They’re pretty much the same, similar weather,” said Peter, noting two significant differences, one being that the sun in the summer hardly sets and in winter hardly rises. The other is the water, described by Peter as “400 to 700 feet deep everywhere.”

            The trip around Martha’s Vineyard was conducted at an average of a quarter mile from shore, except for the stretch getting down and the stretch getting back. Using the navigation app on his phone, Peter took the inflatable out of its skiff spot at Mattapoisett Wharf.

            “We left Mattapoisett just after 5:00 am.”

            Looking at a map, the brothers traveled in a counter-clockwise direction, launching from Mattapoisett Harbor and aiming south-southwest toward Gay Head.

            Traveling at an estimated 13 miles per hour, the brothers went the first 14 miles and in an estimated hour and five minutes, reached Robinsons Hole at its narrowest a 215-yard space between Naushon and Pasque islands, part of the network of islands that acts as a breaker between Martha’s Vineyard and the South Coast.

            “Buzzards Bay was choppy, more than we hoped for and we almost turned around. But when we got to Robinsons and the sun was rising, we pushed through, and I’m glad we did,” said Peter. “Entering Vineyard Sound it was glass, a mirror. We skimmed across the water. The only disturbance was the bubbling of fish and the turning of the tide.”

            They only had to go half as far to reach Menemsha (Chilmark), an “easy” 7.5 miles and 35 minutes. Staying on course, the brothers were often ahead of the schedule they had because they were able to cut through the calm waters at 15 mph.

            “We banked due west towards Gay Head, lighthouse in sight. It was an easy 4-mile stretch, only taking another 19 minutes. We don’t draw much water, so we hugged the coast closer than most of the fishing boats, but I was checking the Nav App on my phone often, just in case,” said Peter, noting an uptick in waves. “As we cornered Gay Head point, the seas chopped up – probably the sharp, depth changes since we were so close to the coast. But the sea was soon smooth again, just as we hit the southwest side of the island.”

            Peter described their stretch to Squibnocket Point as “glorious, a 5-mile rip taking 23 minutes. The cliffs were lit with a deep orange by the rising sun, and the air was starting to change.”

            There, they filled their gas tank.

            Spectacular in its cliffs and steep terrain, the west end of Martha’s Vineyard presents a wall to the seafarer not unlike most of Block Island (Rhode Island).

            “Seeing land from the ocean is different. You get a different view,” said Peter, recalling his trip into Acadia National Park in Maine. “We had plans if it got too rough. … Buzzards Bay is probably going to be the worst. We brought enough anchor lines so, if the motor died and we were stuck out there, we would just anchor and call somebody. … You want to be careful.”

            From an average of a quarter mile from the shore, lifeguards could be seen on the south, ocean-facing side of the Vineyard.

            The 18-mile trek from west to east along the south-facing coast of the Vineyard was considered “a hike,” taking an hour and 23 minutes.

“Cliffs turned to hills. Beaches were baron with the occasional early morning walker. We stopped halfway for a snack and to call our dad. ‘Wow! It is beautiful out there!’” Peter wrote in a summary of the trip. “The blue sky was open, not a cloud. The sun was getting higher and warming our faces. Beaches, as far as the eye could see. Houses – mansions actually – became visible and disappeared just as quickly behind dunes as we cruised the coast.”

            The brothers noticed lifeguards doing sit-ups in advance of the day’s beach crowd.

            “We were seeing the island through different eyes. They were looking out at us, and we were looking back at everyone else and the Vineyard. Just us in our lil’ ole boat,” wrote Peter.

            They reached the Wasque Point Wildlife Management Area on schedule and made the loop around Cape Poge Lighthouse.

            “We strayed from our chartered course here – the weather and water was too nice,” said Peter, noting their decision to head straight to East Chop Lighthouse with a pitstop at Jaws Bridge. “Well, we actually decided to put underneath it and, while we were at it, stand up and touch the bottom of the bridge – check! We cut the engine for a sandwich and a soda.”

            Peter described festive activity, “boats everywhere, zooming back and forth, chasing the schools of fish all around us.”

            After once again filled their tank, the brothers hit harder seas from East Chop Lighthouse to Woods Hole, the return leg north to the mainland 6 miles, taking 28 minutes. By now the seas were crashing against the vessel, spraying water from all directions.

            “It didn’t matter,” Peter writes. “The sun was high, and the air was warm. If anything, it was refreshing.”

            Woods Hole presented heavy boat traffic coming in all sizes. Practically unnoticeable amidst larger craft, the brothers tailed a big sailboat for protection.

            “We stuffed the front end of the inflatable once, midchannel, a clencher for sure. But, we held strong and kept a steady pace, reading the currents and standing waves,” wrote Peter.

            The straight, 10-mile stretch back to Mattapoisett required one more fill-up, and that was still cutting it close.

            “Before we knew it, we could see Ned’s Point and with a shake of the gas tank we opened knew we’d make it,” he said.

            The Perkins brothers were back in their skiff stop before noon, having logged 74 nautical miles in 6 hours and 42 minutes, including their stops.

            The circumnavigation of the Vineyard yielded spectacular views and some unruly seas but mostly a fun adventure that will define a summer that is not quite over.

            “We’ll be out in the boat until it’s too cold to be out in the boat,” said Peter. “We’re usually the last ones to take the boat out of the water.”

By Mick Colageo

Marion Cultural Council Seeks Local Funding Proposals

Marion Cultural Council is excited to receive online grant applications for individuals and organizations for art and STEM-related projects that will help to enrich the Marion community. Marion Cultural Council has set an October 15 deadline for organizations, schools, and individuals to apply for grants that support cultural activities and proposals for community-oriented arts, humanities, and science programs in the community. These grants can support a variety of artistic projects and activities in Marion– including exhibits, festivals, field trips, short-term artist residencies, or performances in schools, workshops, and lectures.

            The Marion Cultural Council is part of a network of 329 Local Cultural Councils serving all 351 cities and towns in the Commonwealth. The LCC Program is the largest grassroots cultural funding network in the nation, supporting thousands of community-based projects in the arts, sciences, and humanities every year. The state legislature provides an annual appropriation to the Massachusetts Cultural Council, a state agency, which then allocates funds to each community.

            For questions regarding the Marion Cultural Council, contact marionculturalcouncil@gmail.com Online application forms, a full list of priorities and guidelines and more information about the Local Cultural Council Program and a list of the council’s priorities are available online at www.mass-culture.org/Marion

Saltmarsh Mattapoisett: Status and Potential Actions

Please join Mattapoisett Land Trust (MLT) and Woods Hole Group on Thursday September 19 from 4:00-5:30 pm at the Mattapoisett Fire Station (Training Room) for a presentation about our local saltmarshes. Volunteers from MLT and staff from Woods Hole Group will present the results of a June 2024 study of the 250 acres of saltmarsh west of Mattapoisett Neck Road.

            This large saltmarsh system is suffering damage as a result of many factors. The study identified these factors, projected future marsh conditions with rising sea levels and developed possible actions to improve or restore the health and resilience of the marsh. The study was funded by a grant from the Massachusetts Coastal Zone Management office to MLT and the Town of Mattapoisett.

            This presentation is open to the public and will include a question-and-answer session. Please join us.

Harbormaster’s Actions Affirmed in Two Cases

The Negative Boxes 2 and 3 Determination of Applicability issued the Town of Marion by its own Conservation Commission on August 28 for a seawall fix was rather brief compared to a more involved discussion the commissioners would hold with a waterfront homeowner whose hired hands were found to be mowing in a jurisdictional area.

            Harbormaster Adam Murphy, though not in attendance on August 28, was at the center of both cases, the first a temporary solution he is spearheading to protect the seawall while the town figures out a long-term plan for the eroding earth on the landward side of the wall close by the new Maritime Center at Island Wharf.

            After closing three brief public hearings, the commissioners revisited a recent discussion regarding unpermitted work that occurred at 5 Main Street.

            The homeowner, Sanford H. Russell Jr., complied with the commission’s request to visit the site and was present on August 28 to reiterate his intent was the same as it’s been for the past 23 years: to remove “the flotsam and jetsam” from the site.

            Russell explained that workers hired to rake up the debris went beyond that, an activity he said he and his wife Michelle Russell were unhappy with because it ruins their view. He said it’s starting to grow back and explained that his activities have always included the cleaning up of trash left by others.

            “This year, we had an occurrence,” said Russell, asking the commissioners to “view it as such.” Russell suspects a language barrier with the workers contributed to the outcome and said, “We won’t be asking them to help us next time.”

            Commissioner Shaun Walsh referenced prior comment made by Michelle Russell, noting that similar activity had occurred in the past and that then-Harbormaster Isaac Perry was aware of it. Walsh said he recently reached out to Perry regarding that exchange and noted for the record that Perry strongly denies any implication he condoned the illegal activity.

            Walsh reported that Perry told him he had never seen any mowing in the resource area and if he had, he would have done as Harbormaster Adam Murphy did and reported it to the Conservation Commission. Walsh acknowledged the possibility of a breakdown in communications between Perry and Michelle Russell.

            “I think it’s really important to understand what the question was and what the intent of the answer was,” said Mr. Russell, who was attending the meeting in person. “The question, as my wife understood it, was, ‘have you cleaned up this flotsam and jetsam in the past before?’ And the answer was yes. In fact, Isaac was aware that we did this.

            “Isaac has come over … taken a look, ‘what are you doing?’ ‘Cleaning up the flotsam and jetsam.’… I went over and talked to Isaac as well. … The question wasn’t, ‘did you weed-whack it?’” recalled Russell, emphasizing Perry’s knowledge of their regular activities and the context of those conversations.

            Walsh acknowledged Russell’s clarification and recommended the commission reserve its right to ensure revegetation should it not occur naturally. Walsh said images from Google Earth Pro can isolate conditions from the past to inform the process.

            Russell said the growth in the area has been asymmetrical, in a trapezoid shape, due to the imbalance of sun exposure with the neighboring property. “We like the growth, so we hope it comes back as expected,” he said.

            Russell said he has enjoyed good relationships with Perry and Murphy but wishes the town could act on more impromptu and informal bases upon the discovery of improper activities such as occurred on his property.

            Walsh asserted that Murphy acted properly in this case.

            “They’re our eyes on the coast because they’re out there all the time,” said Walsh. “A lot of other places in Marion, we would not necessarily see unless we’re out on a boat, so I think what Adam did was appropriate because he alerted the commission to what he correctly viewed as an unpermittable activity.”

            Russell acknowledged the legal fact of the matter but feels Marion can avoid scenarios like the one he and his wife wound up embroiled in by addressing things on the spot.

            “This is a small town, everybody knows each other,” said Russell. “Had (Murphy) walked over and talked to the people we supposedly had raking up and said, ‘Are you supposed to be doing that?’ They would have stopped, which is the goal. … Adam saw it but didn’t feel capable of quickly going over there and saying, ‘hey, hold on guys. Let me just check on this. Take a break.’ … That’s what I’d like to see in this town.”

            The commission took Russell’s comments under advisement with a plan to revisit the site next June. Vice Chairman Emil Assing suggested Russell stay in touch with Conservation Agent Doug Guey-Lee, who publicly thanked Russell for the visit to hash out the matter.

            Bob Rogers of G.A.F. Engineering sat in for colleague Brian Grady, who was representing before the Wareham Zoning Board of Appeals in the case of 262B Seaside Realty Trust. The applicant filed a RDA for proposed construction of a new house, driveway, utilities and grading at Seaside Lane.

            Rogers explained that the lot in question had received an Order of Conditions in 2018, approving a bigger house and a pool. Work was permitted in the buffer zone to bordering wetlands.

            “They never proceeded with that project, they never recorded the Order of Conditions and they asked us to renew the permitting and to do so with a smaller house with no pool, so the only the only resource area that we’re in is land subject to coastal-storm flowage, which is the Flood Zone 8 and 15,” explained Rogers of the revised project. “And so we felt, with the scaled-back project and no work proposed in the buffer zone, that … and not having had the previous Order of Conditions recorded, we thought we would just come in with a Request for Determination of Applicability.”

            To get himself up to speed, Rogers studied the documents and on the day of the public hearing visited the site. Conservation Commission Chairman Matt Shultz said that a few of the members did visit on August 24.

            Rogers said the lots there are narrow and so is the house. He said there is thick vegetation in the uplands between the narrow house and the wetland. The house is 12 feet off the property line closest to Converse Road.

            “We are proposing roof-runoff infiltration units,” said Rogers.

            Shultz asked about the type of foundation for the house.

            Rogers said the first floor (and living space and utilities) must be above the 15-foot elevation, and the plan shows a foundation at the 20-foot elevation. “We basically have to stay out of the V Zone,” he said but noted he had not seen any architectural renderings prior to the public hearing.

            Guey-Lee and Assing expressed interest in landscaping and the future of land following the planned construction, especially outside the limit of work. Rogers said the new application has proposed no work inside the 100-foot buffer zone and said any work planned there would require another RDA filing.

            The commission voted to issue a Negative Box 2 Determination, allowing the project to go forward as planned.

            Kathleen Welch was issued a Negative Box 2 Determination for repairs to an existing driveway and entryway including installation of a granite step around the front masonry entryway at 82 West Avenue.

            The commissioners were impressed with seawall work done by Paul and Linda Vivino, along with minor improvements to their home at 12 West Avenue and voted to issue two Certificates of Compliance.

            Bryan Marshall, 25 Pine Hill Lane, was issued a partial Certificates of Compliance for work done at that site.

            The next meeting of the Marion Conservation Commission is scheduled for Wednesday, September 11, at 7:00 pm at the Police Station on Route 6.

Marion Conservation Commission

By Mick Colageo

Annelise Susanne Dexter

Annelise Susanne Dexter, 66, of Rochester, MA, passed away unexpectedly on September 2, 2024. Born in Denmark, she was the daughter of Fritse and Tove Jorgensen.

            From her upbringing on a farm in a small Danish village to the coast of Massachusetts, her love of animals and nature was something she held dear to her heart. Whether she was making blueberry muffins, serving a hotdog from her food truck Danish Dogs, or just by being a beautiful presence, everyone she met was deeply touched by her infectious joy for life.

            She is survived by her loving husband, Jim Camacho of Rochester, son, Adrian Dexter of Marion, stepdaughter Jamie Camacho and granddaughter Caitlin Westgate of Wareham, stepson Michael Camacho of Rochester, sisters Benedikte and Ruth Jorgensen and nieces Lena and Anna Semberlund of Denmark.

            She will be dearly missed by her family, friends, and Danish Dogs customers.

            Services will be private.

??????????????

Nelson P. Costa

Nelson P. Costa, 78, of Marion passed away peacefully on Monday, September 2, 2024. He was the husband of Ronalie E. Wood.

            Born in Fenais da Luz, Portugal, he was the son of the late Deodato Costa Lopes and Maria Couto.

            Nelson enjoyed magic tricks and traveling, especially visiting the Azores where he still had family. He liked tinkering and fixing anything that broke in the house. He loved parking near the Marion harbor and looking at the boats.

            Nelson’s visitation will be held Friday, September 13, 2024 from 4-6 pm at the Saunders-Dwyer Mattapoisett Home for Funerals, 50 County Road, Mattapoisett. For online guestbook, please visit www.saundersdwyer.com

Brad Hathaway Sets New Goals

The 92-year-old activist whose 2023-24 winter goal was to live to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Mattapoisett Land Trust enjoyed that event in April at the Munro Preserve but isn’t stopping there.

            At the conclusion of a ceremonial, 27,000th-mile walk down Aucoot Road from Bowman Road to his home on August 31, Brad Hathaway told a gathering of nearly 40 people that he wants to see the endowment funding the annual art scholarship created in memory of his late wife Priscilla Hathaway grow to $25,000.

            As cofounders of the MLT, the Hathaways have long been looking for ways to protect land in Mattapoisett, especially coastal areas threatened by rising tides and major storms.

            Priscilla Hathaway was an art teacher, so after her passing, Brad Hathaway asked the MLT about establishing a scholarship for an Old Rochester Regional High School art student in her memory.

            “The Land Trust – thanks to them – said they would do that,” Hathaway told the gathering.

            He said that through the first two years of the scholarship’s activity, including the paying out of $1,000, it had yet to be fully funded. “I was told we’d need between 20 and 25 thousand,” he said.

            Former MLT president, now treasurer Gary Johnson said the scholarship is now close to being fully funded, estimating approximately $22,500 in the account. Hathaway wants to push for $25,000.

            “We don’t know what’s going to happen in the future … I would just as soon make it $25,000 and someday increase the scholarship,” Hathaway said, mindful of the clock because of his appointment for dialysis treatment.

            Johnson explained that the money will be set aside as an endowment and that the funds won’t be used for anything else, only to fund the Priscilla Hathaway Scholarship. The announcement drew applause from the gathering at the finish line outside the gate to Hathaway’s driveway.

            Two years ago, along the same stretch of road, Hathaway celebrated his round-the-world milestone of 25,000 career-walking miles. On August 31, he made it 27,000. He was accompanied by family, friends, news reporters and even bagpiper Sue Maxwell of Marion.

            Maxwell, who also serenaded Hathaway during his 25,000th mile walk in 2023, spends her winters in Florida and will be part of a team of bagpipers competing in January in Orlando. Her appearance on August 31 at the home stretch brought tears to Hathaway’s eyes. He gave pause and looked back at the applauding crowd before resuming his paces.

            Despite his age and his ailments including kidney failure and Parkinson’s disease, Hathaway made sure to confirm Maxwell’s availability for his next milestone walk.

By Mick Colageo

Marion Preservation Committees

Many people are asking why Marion seems to have several different preservation groups and what each one does. Here we explain the various titles and responsibilities:

            The Marion Historical Commission is a Town-appointed board and an important part of municipal government. Each city and town in Massachusetts has one. Historic Commissions are responsible for community-wide historic preservation planning and are guided and supported by the Massachusetts Historical Commission in Boston.

            The Marion Historical Commission’s first objective has been to update and complete a town-wide survey of historic buildings and places in Marion, which now include digital recording and availability on the statewide MACRIS website. The Commission also plays a leadership role in public education about the community’s historic resources and why they are important to preserve. Local commissions also prioritize properties for listing in the National Register of Historic Places, the nation’s honorary listing of buildings, structures, sites, objects and districts significant in our nation’s history, culture, architecture or archeology worthy of preservation.

            The Historical Commission maintains a presence on the Town of Marion website, including our Mission Statement and links to important local historic maps, existing inventory forms and resources for ongoing preservation projects.

            The Marion Village Local Historic District Study Committee was appointed by the Select Board in 2023 to explore the possibility of creating a Local Historic District as a way to ensure that Marion Village continues to maintain its historic and unique sense of place. Major changes such as demolition, new additions and new construction within a specified district would come under review to ensure the Village’s historic character is not being negatively impacted.

            If a Local Historic District bylaw is enacted at a future date, a new committee would be formed to oversee the design review process according to the provisions of the bylaw. This new Marion Historic District Commission would be a Town-appointed board of local residents who bring an array of talents and knowledge of history, architecture, development, construction and real estate backgrounds.

            The Sippican Historical Society, which most people are most familiar with, is a privately funded 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization with dues-paying membership. Founded in 1963, its mission is Education, Historical Preservation and Outreach to increase interest in and support for Marion’s history. Through its museum, lectures, tours and involvement in the preservation of the Post Office, General Store, Town House, Music Hall, Captain Hadley House and other historic properties, the Society has played a key role in the preservation of Marion’s historic fabric. The Society and its museum are housed in the historic Walton Nye Ellis House.

            The Marion Historical Commission and the Sippican Historical Society work closely together to promote preservation awareness and appreciation through public lectures and other programs.

Marion Republican Town Committee

The Marion Republican Town Committee will conduct its next monthly meeting on Monday, September 9 at 7:00 pm at the Marion Music Hall, 164 Front Street, Marion. The public and new members welcome. We look forward to seeing you.

Open Comment to Open Meetings

The Rochester School Committee has voted unanimously to move the Open Comment section of its regular meetings to the beginning of the agenda.

            Chairperson Sharon Hartley introduced a discussion on Open Comment during the committee’s August 29 meeting. She referred to a meeting of school-committee chairpersons to discuss the matter.

            Her takeaway from that gathering was that school committee is by nature a business meeting, unlike the many municipal boards, commissions and committees that necessarily involve the participation of residents.

            The chairpersons determined that in the interests of completing business, Open Comment should remain at the end of the school-committee agenda but recognizing that the decision falls to each school committee. The chair would retain the authority to move Open Comment to a different place on the agenda.

            Member Kate Duggan motioned to put Open Comment at the beginning of the agenda, and member Josh Trombly seconded the motion. Member Robin Rounseville said she has feelings on both sides of the issue but feels like emotion has too often outweighed a respectful approach, reminding the members that they are volunteers.

            “Sometimes the misconception is that the people here (commenting) are prevalent,” said Rounseville, who said committee members are often receiving feedback outside of meetings that differs from what is expressed during Open Comment.

            Trombly acknowledged Rounseville’s concern but reiterated his advocacy for moving Open Comment to the start.

            “I can tell you from sitting in the audience for a long time that it’s difficult,” he said. “That’s when you come from that place of frustration, when the item that you wanted to discuss gets voted on first and then you have to just sit there and then pop off about it at the end.

            “I hope that things would be a little more respectful if people had the opportunity to say their piece at the beginning.”

            A subsequent vote was taken to decide whether to add a response section for the committee. The current policy defines Open Comment as an opportunity for citizens to speak in public session but does not obligate the school committee to engage those comments or respond.

            During Open Comment at the conclusion of the meeting, both Jeff Costa and Karen Thomas thanked the committee for its new seating arrangement (in which the members are all facing the attending public) and for voting to move Open Comment to the top of future agendas. They also expressed their belief that the committee failed to apply reason in a vote to reject a book donation.

            The 3-2 vote to reject a book about a dog in the Iditarod was preceded by a lengthy discussion about process.

            On recommendation of the school librarian, the committee voted to accept the donation of a collection of books from Plumb Library and a single donation from the Rochester Memorial School Parent Teacher Organization, “Survived the Battle of D-Day” (1944). Also on the librarian’s recommendation, the committee voted against accepting resident Sarah Bourque’s donation of “Granite” by late Iditarod champion Susan Butcher.

            “I read the book, I think it’s fantastic. I think it encompasses a lot of the values that we’re trying to (encourage) in the schools,” said Trombly before the vote. “It’s inspiring. It’s about the first woman to finish in the top 10 in the Iditarod. (Butcher) was dyslexic, she was born in Massachusetts, the first Saturday of March is Susan Butcher Day in Alaska.”

            Trombly asked for clarification on the process of the library media specialist’s recommendation against its acceptance because he found it hard to believe anyone who reads the book would not find it to be “excellent.”

            The Iditarod, the annual cross-continent, sled-dog race, has been heavily criticized as inhumane by animal-rights activists, including PETA, but a 2013 article in “Psychology Today” identified Butcher as an advocate for change in how racing dogs are trained and treated.

            Assistant Superintendent of Teaching and Learning Dr. Shari Fedorowicz explained the process as being consistent and said that the specialists look for professional reviews.

            Trombly said he has read the policy and realizes that the book in question lacks reviews from one of the identified preferred sources, but at the same time he asserted that books being carried in the school library refer readers to Good Reads and Amazon.

            “I guess it’s the inconsistency that bothers me a little bit, and I think we’re missing an opportunity on a great book,” he said. “I don’t know Ms. Bourque at all, but that’s just my opinion.”

            Member Anne Fernandes “seconded” Trombly’s comments.

            Fedorowicz confirmed that the recommendation against accepting the donation was based on a lack of reviews necessary to justify a recommendation. Fedorowicz also stated that the school librarians do their own review and do not rely on sources alone.

            Rounseville said to change the process and go against librarian’s recommendations would be a departure from how the committee has handled donations all along.

            Chairperson Sharon Hartley said she finds the librarian’s process to be “very thorough and very serious.”

            Fernandes said it’s not about the librarian but the process.

            Duggan said part of the process has been to recognize policy and consistently follow it.

            “If we don’t have some standard, then we have no standard. I don’t know that we want no standard for book inclusion,” she said.

            Fernandes reiterated that the policy dictates, as confirmed earlier by Nelson, that the committee has the final say.

            Nelson confirmed that a committee approval would put a book in the school library.

            Trombly reiterated his request that the voted be tabled to the next meeting to allow members time to look at the book for themselves.

            The motion to reject it was on the table, and Hartley sought to see through the vote. Hartley, Rounseville and Duggan voted to reject the donation of “Granite,” while Fernandes and Trombly voted against the book’s rejection.

            Rochester Memorial School Principal Heidi Letendre laid out a two-year, School Improvement Plan for the committee, using a PowerPoint presentation. The committee heard the presentation and voted to approve the plan.

            The committee reelected Hartley as chairperson (Fernandes voted against) and voted unanimously to elect Duggan as the new vice chair.

            By a 3-2 vote, Rounseville was elected Rochester representative to the ORR School Committee, and Trombly, who received the opposing votes, was unanimously elected to join Hartley and Fernandes as Rochester’s representative on the Union #55 side of the Joint School Committee.

            At the start of the meeting, Hartley celebrated the beginning of the new school year, noting the excitement that comes with the new beginning.

            Superintendent of Schools Mike Nelson welcomed Jaime Curley, the ORR District’s new assistant superintendent of Student Services. Nelson also publicly acknowledged that the interim tag has been removed from Letendre’s role as RMS principal.

            The following RMS staff members were recognized for reaching milestones in years of community service: for 25 years of service, Grade 6 teacher Tracey Forns, Paraprofessional Debra Moniz, and Physical Education teacher Kevin Woodward; for 20 years, Kindergarten teachers Cindy Baronas and Melissa Weigel, Paraprofessional Janice Bateman, Grade 4 teacher Shaunda Griffin, Grade 1 teacher Ana Lenahan, and Assistant Principal Charles West; for 15 years, Special Education Secretary Kim Amato, Grade 2 teachers Michelle Bradley and Tess Hedblom, Grade 4 teacher Julia Cabral, and Media Specialist Sandra Sollauer; and for 10 years, Nurse Ellen Murphy, and School Adjustment Counselor Jamie Pacheco.

            Margaret DeMello has reached 50 years of service in the ORR District. Reaching 25 years of service at the district level are John Ashley and Susan Wheeler (Technology), and reaching the 10-year mark this year are Nelson and ORR Website Coordinator Erin Bednarczyk.

            New additions include Carla Correia, who joins RMS as a lunch/recess aide, while Geralyn Gherard joins RMS as a paraprofessional, and Alex Sylvaria is a new Grade 4 teacher.

            Nelson and Letendre discussed opening-day faculty activities, and Nelson thanked Project 351 students for their early-morning assistance and for the Tri-Town police departments for their presence in all communities on opening day.

            The committee took a tour of Rochester Memorial School with Facilities Director Gene Jones.             The next meeting of the Rochester School Committee is scheduled for Thursday, October 3, at 6:30 pm at Rochester Memorial School, and the next meeting of the Joint School Committee is scheduled for Thursday, September 26, at 6:30 pm at the ORR Junior High media room on Route 6 in Mattapoisett

Rochester School Committee

By Mick Colageo